issue 1: is there an Offer?
Law: Section 2(a) Contract Law 1950
rules- section 4(1) CA
include relevant cases
Apply(fact): you should link the laws to the given cases
conclusion: yes, there is an offer/ No, there is not an offer
issue 2: is there an acceptance?
Law: Cumulative effect of section 2(a) Contract Law 1950, sectioen 2(b) CA and section 10(1) CA
Acceptance must be absolute and unqualified (section 7(a) CA)
Included relevant cases
apply: Y is not accepting but counter offering, counter offering does not form contact
conclusion: 你应该会conclude了吧
issue 3: Did Z breach the law of offer?
Law: revocation of offer, section 5(1) Contract Law 1950, section 6(a) CA, section 4(3)(a) CA and section 4(3)(b)CA
然后apply跟conclusion
issues就是整个事件的关键点
这个case来说
你就要知道怎样形成contract
for a contract to be formed, there must be an offer and must be accepted
所以你要先证明有offer,然后看有没有acceptance
你老师也没有错
但是不可能每个句子都是issue
a 和 d 肯定可以的
b 和 c 是个问题
b还可以,但是option是没有law的,你只可以include relevant cases
然后你要怎么写?
seek for more information? come under which section? 作者: yedda 时间: 2012-11-20 10:55 PM
Jayrein 发表于 2012-11-20 10:31 PM
a 和 d 肯定可以的
b 和 c 是个问题
b还可以,但是option是没有law的,你只可以include relevant cases ...
可以吗??
revocation
section4,5,6 of contracts act 1950
routledge v grant
那个seeking the information,option ,我没想过要写law 作者: Jayrein 时间: 2012-11-20 11:00 PM